Kate Spencer, In a New York Minute

Franny’s day goes from bad to worse when, on her way home from being laid off, her dress gets caught in the subway doors and rips apart. A handsome stranger gives her his suit jacket so that she can cover up. And that would have been the end of the story, except that a bystander caught the whole thing on camera. Now Franny and the subway guy, Hayes, have been dubbed #SubwayQTs, and the local news is doing a story on their supposed romance. It’s not true, of course; but as Franny and Hayes continue to bump into each other, it feels like fate may be nudging them together after all. This was a pleasant enough rom-com that really wants to be described as “a love letter to New York City,” and maybe I’m just a grumpy old lady now, but that type of narrative does nothing for me. I wasn’t particularly invested in the romance, which didn’t have any obstacles beyond the characters’ general obtuseness. There were some cute moments, and I can see a version of this plot working as a movie, but overall there’s just nothing substantial about this book.

Katherine Arden, The Unicorn Hunters

Anne, duchess of Brittany, is facing a crisis. The king of France is pressing for her hand in marriage so that he can absorb the duchy into his own kingdom—and if she refuses, he’ll take it by force. Her only hope is to marry another powerful ruler who can help her fight the French, but in return, she’ll have to leave Brittany and give up her role as its leader. She plans to marry secretly in the forest of Brocéliande, organizing a unicorn hunt as a cover story. But Brocéliande is an uncanny place, on the boundary between the mortal world and the Lost Lands, and Anne soon learns she has more powerful enemies than France to contend with. I absolutely loved this book, which combines so many of my favorite things. Give me medieval Brittany, fantasy elements, and a romance, and I’m sold! Arden’s writing is vivid and magical, and Anne is a wonderfully drawn character based on a real historical person. I’ve loved every book by Arden I’ve read so far, but this one just may be my favorite. It will definitely be one of my top books of the year!

D.E. Stevenson, The Baker’s Daughter

Sue Pringle has lived in the small town of Beilford, Scotland, all her life. Her father is the baker, and her grandfather owns a prosperous shop. But she’s somewhat bored with her life and eager to try something new. The perfect opportunity arises when a painter from London, John Darnay, moves to town needing a housekeeper. Sue takes the job and soon finds her world expanding. She also develops strong feelings for Darnay, but his social station is far above hers, and he happens to be married already. I enjoy Stevenson’s quiet, romantic, character-driven books, and this one is no exception. I liked getting both Sue’s and Darnay’s perspectives throughout the novel, and the secondary characters are very well drawn. But readers should beware of some distasteful racism that is typical of the period. I don’t remember other Stevenson novels being this egregious, so if you haven’t read the author before, I wouldn’t recommend starting here. But as someone who likes Stevenson’s general vibe, I still found a lot to enjoy in this book.