Mini-Reviews: Bird, Clockwork, Murder

Josie Silver, The Two Lives of Lydia Bird

When Lydia Bird’s fiancé, Freddie, dies in a car accident, she’s absolutely devastated. Even mundane daily tasks like bathing and eating feel unbearably difficult, and sleep is out of the question. But when she takes an experimental sleeping pill her doctor prescribes, she has a vividly lucid dream — or perhaps enters a parallel universe — in which Freddie is still alive. Soon her waking life becomes a chore as she waits desperately for the next time she can sleep and be with Freddie. But as time passes, she must decide where she truly belongs. This was an interesting book to start the new year with, since it’s all about exploring what-if scenarios, remembering the past, and making choices about the future. The novel is very slow-paced, but that makes sense, as more than anything else it’s a story about grief and navigating life after a big loss. There’s a slight element of romance that I didn’t find totally satisfying, but otherwise I liked the book and would recommend it if the premise appeals to you.

Nancy Campbell Allen, Beauty and the Clockwork Beast

In this steampunk twist on the gothic novel, Lucy Pickett travels to Blackwell Manor to care for her beloved cousin, Kate, who is suffering from a mysterious illness after her recent marriage to the earl of Blackwell’s younger brother. At the manor, Lucy experiences many terrors, from ghostly apparitions to the earl himself, whose surly and intimidating demeanor hides dangerous secrets. She and the earl, Miles, eventually team up to discover what’s causing Kate’s illness, who’s behind a spate of vampire attacks in the area, and who murdered Miles’s recently deceased wife and sister. So yes, there’s a lot going on in this book (and I didn’t even mention the werewolf!), but it’s easy enough to follow the narrative. I liked plucky Lucy and brooding Miles, and though the book is steamless, their mutual attraction is clear. I wasn’t as impressed with the book as I remember being when I first read it, but I enjoyed it nonetheless and look forward to continuing with the series.

Delano Ames, She Shall Have Murder

Jane Hamish, a clerk in a London law office, is writing a mystery novel in which her coworkers and legal clients are the main characters. Her boyfriend, Dagobert Brown, instigated the project and insists that Mrs. Robjohn, an elderly client who’s convinced mysterious men are out to get her, should be the murder victim. But when Mrs. Robjohn really does die — apparently due to an accidental gas leak in her home — Dagobert is convinced she was actually murdered and decides to investigate. This is my first encounter with Golden Age mystery writer Delano Ames, but it won’t be my last because I thoroughly enjoyed this book! Jane narrates the story and has a delightfully witty voice, and I’m intrigued by her relationship with Dagobert (this is book #1 in the series, but there’s clearly some interesting backstory that will hopefully be explored in later installments). The mystery itself is fine but not remarkable; the book’s strengths are its characterizations and style. I’ll be looking out for more in this series.

Mini-Reviews: Mistress, Princess, Death

Mary Balogh, The Secret Mistress

Lady Angeline Dudley has no interest in marrying a rake like her brothers; she just wants a steady, responsible man who will nevertheless love her passionately. So when Edward Ailsbury, the earl of Heyward, chivalrously rescues her from the improper attentions of a rake, she falls in love with him at once. Meanwhile, Edward knows he needs to marry, and Angeline is certainly eligible, but her outspoken, slightly wild behavior horrifies him. He’s also drawn to her despite himself, but he has trouble reconciling his feelings with his long-held image of the perfect wife. This is the final book of Balogh’s “Mistress” trilogy and, in my opinion, the most enjoyable. Angeline is a somewhat unconventional heroine in that she’s not particularly deep or intelligent; rather, she’s a flighty chatterbox with terrible fashion sense but a very warm heart. Edward isn’t a typical hero, either — he’s very responsible and practical and not rakish at all. I loved them both and was rooting for them to get together, although the last few chapters got a bit too flowery and sentimental for my taste. Still, overall I quite liked this one, which is a bit lighter than Balogh’s usual fare!

Philip Pullman, The Tin Princess

This final book in the Sally Lockhart series doesn’t actually have much Sally in it. Rather, the plot centers around Adelaide, who vanished at the end of The Ruby in the Smoke but has now resurfaced as the wife of the crown prince of a tiny Central European country. Accompanied by intrepid detective Jim Taylor and German tutor Becky Winter, she must travel to Razkavia and learn how to be a princess. But court intrigues, foreign interference, and assassination plots threaten both their own safety and that of Razkavia as a whole. As with the other books in this series, this is an entertaining adventure novel that’s chock-full of plot. The characterization is a bit less convincing; I didn’t believe Adelaide would become an expert politician so quickly, and the romance between her and Jim is barely sketched in. So while this is a fun series and I’m glad I read it, I won’t be keeping it on my shelves.

Catherine Lloyd, Death Comes to Kurland Hall

Lucy Harrington is back in Kurland St. Mary to help her best friend, Sophia, with Sophia’s upcoming wedding. One of the wedding guests, Mrs. Chingford, is a conniving widow who delights in spreading malicious gossip and antagonizes several of the other guests. On the wedding day, Mrs. Chingford falls down a flight of stairs and dies, and Lucy is convinced it’s no accident. She and Major Robert Kurland must once again work together to discover the killer — and sort out their complicated feelings for each other. This is another enjoyable installment of the Kurland St. Mary series, though it’s not a particularly memorable one in terms of the mystery. But I do like the way the world is being built out and how some of the recurring series characters are being developed. Lucy and Robert’s romance also takes a step forward in this one, though I wish the book had focused on it more…there was so much buildup, but the resolution fell flat. Regardless, though, I’ll certainly continue with the series.

Mini-Reviews: Curse, Moonflower, Pearls

Elizabeth C. Bunce, A Curse Dark as Gold

Charlotte Miller has been struggling to run Stirwaters, the mill she’s inherited from her father. Stirwaters is plagued by bad luck; the local townsfolk say it’s cursed. Charlotte is far too practical to believe in curses, but as mishap after mishap befalls Stirwaters, she’s determined to do whatever it takes to save the mill — even accept the help of the mysterious Jack Spinner, who claims he can spin straw into gold. But his help comes with a price, and eventually he’ll ask for something Charlotte is unwilling to pay. I really liked this retelling of Rumpelstiltskin when I first read it; this time around, I still think it’s very well done, but it might be a bit too slow for me. Most of the book is just Charlotte becoming more and more miserable as Stirwaters is threatened, and she pushes all her loved ones away to deal with the problem alone, which I found frustrating. But Charlotte’s community is well portrayed, there’s a sweet romance with realistic ups and downs, and I liked the resolution to the curse. I’d recommend this for fans of atmospheric fairytale retellings who don’t mind a slower pace.

Lauren Willig, The Lure of the Moonflower

The final book in the Pink Carnation series focuses on the Carnation herself, Miss Jane Wooliston, who is on a mission to locate the missing Portuguese queen before the French do. But since she doesn’t know the country or the language, she’ll need the help of Jack Reid, a British agent (and former French agent) known as the Moonflower. But will she be able to trust him with the mission — and her heart? The plot of this book is even less substantial than usual; even the climactic scene doesn’t have particularly high stakes, and the matter of the missing queen feels like an afterthought. The meat of the book, though, is Jane and Jack’s relationship, which I think is quite well done. Since Jane’s been a pivotal series character since book #1, it was important that she have a love interest worthy of her, and Jack definitely fits the bill. The book also gives us one last look at several of the other series couples, which was fun but a little overkill. I also appreciated Willig’s “where are they now” note at the end of the book, which did a pretty good job of wrapping things up. Overall, I think this is one of the better books in the series and definitely a fitting end to the Pink Carnation’s adventures.

Darcie Wilde, The Secret of the Lost Pearls

In this installment of the Rosalind Thorne series, an old school friend requests Rosalind’s help to discover who stole her valuable pearl necklace. The woman fears that the thief is her youngest sister, Nora, who’s recently returned to the family after a scandalous and ill-fated elopement. But when Rosalind goes to stay with the family, she senses many secrets and soon identifies several other plausible suspects. This book has the same strengths and weaknesses as the previous books in the series: a likable main character and an interesting look at the fringes of Regency high society, but an overly complicated plot that made the book feel like a slog. I think the next book in the series just came out, or will shortly; but while the series has its good points, I’m no longer interested enough to continue. Thankfully, Rosalind and her friends end up in a reasonably good place here, so I won’t feel like I’m abandoning their stories unfinished.

Mini-Reviews: Sugar, Widow, Scorpio

Sarah Addison Allen, The Sugar Queen

Twenty-seven-year-old Josey Cirrini is expected to live at home, take care of her aging mother, and always behave with perfect propriety. While she outwardly conforms to those expectations, she secretly rebels by stashing sweets, junk food, and romance novels in her bedroom closet. Then one day, a local woman named Della Lee Baker moves into her closet and refuses to come out until Josey starts making changes in her life. With Della Lee’s encouragement, Josey finds friendship and even love, but her newfound community is threatened by a sinister stranger. I always like Sarah Addison Allen’s books, which are set in Southern small towns with a hint of magic. This one is probably my favorite because I find Josey very relatable (though thankfully I have a much better mother than she does!). It’s got multiple romances, cozy fall/winter vibes, and a strong emphasis on relationships between women. Recommended, especially for this time of year.

Diana Biller, The Widow of Rose House

Alva Webster has recently returned to America after several years abroad. She’s bought an old house and plans to publish a book about the process of renovating and decorating it. But the house is allegedly haunted, and she can’t convince anyone to come work on it until she does something about the ghost. Enter Professor Samuel Moore, a brilliant scientist with an interest in the supernatural. As he and Alva investigate the possible ghost, they also fall in love, but Alva’s traumatic past may derail their romance. I’d heard good things about this book, and I’m happy to say it lived up to the hype! I enjoyed the relatively uncommon setting of 1870s New York, and I loved the banter between Sam and Alva. Sam is a bit too good to be true — he always reacts perfectly to Alva’s emotional turmoil — but he’s very charming and likable nonetheless. Recommended for fans of historical romance, and I’ll definitely be seeking out more by Biller!

Maggie Stiefvater, The Scorpio Races

Life on the remote island of Thisby revolves around the Scorpio Races, an annual event in which men (it’s always men) ride the dangerous, man-eating water horses native to the seas surrounding the island. Sean Kendrick has won the races several times, and he hopes this time he’ll win enough to finally be able to buy his beloved mount. Meanwhile, Puck Connolly is racing for the very first time, in hopes of somehow convincing her older brother, Gabe, not to move to the mainland. As Sean and Puck train together, they grow closer, but to get what they want — including each other — they’ll have to survive the races first. This is a book of my heart, and it was sheer joy to immerse myself in its world once again. I’m not usually a person who reads for setting, but Thisby is magical and feels as though it must be real. The book is slow and subtle and, while it contains a love story, it doesn’t feel romance-y at all, if that makes sense. For my money, this is Stiefvater’s best book, and I highly recommend it if the premise interests you.

Mini-Reviews: Fight, Familiar, Village

Maureen Lee Lenker, It Happened One Fight

Joan Davis has worked hard to become a famous and beloved movie star, and her goal is nearly in sight. Her only problem is her costar, Dash Howard. Audiences love “Davis and Dash” films, but she can’t stand him, and he’s constantly pranking her on set. When one of his pranks goes spectacularly awry, leaving Dash and Joan legally married, the answer is simple: move production of their current film to Reno, where they can divorce after residing there for six weeks. But as Joan and Dash get to know each other better, they reconsider their plan to separate. This book is obviously inspired by the screwball comedies of the 1930s, and I enjoyed the setting and the movie allusions very much. However, the romance itself fell a bit flat. Mostly, I thought the book dragged on too long — there were several points when Joan and Dash overcame a big conflict and the book could have ended, but instead they had to confront yet another obstacle. I just got a bit tired of it. I’d love to read more historical romance set in this time period, but this one wasn’t as enthralling as I hoped it would be.

Lish McBride, A Little Too Familiar

This cozy paranormal romance centers around Declan, a werewolf, and Lou, an animal mage who specializes in bonding humans to animal familiars. When Declan moves in with Lou and her housemates, the two are immediately attracted to each other, but Declan has a traumatic past that’s left him distrustful of animal mages. When that past comes back to haunt him, he and Lou (and their other housemates and friends) must team up to stop Declan’s enemies. I don’t read a lot of paranormal romance, but I liked this book a lot. All the main characters are kind, well-intentioned people, and the “found family” vibe is strong. The romance worked for me (though it’s definitely racier than I’d prefer), and the suspense plot provided some stakes for the novel, but it’s pretty low-conflict overall. Some of my favorite scenes were when Declan, Lou, and their friends were just hanging out and bantering. There’s at least one sequel to this book, and I definitely plan on picking it up at some point!

Catherine Lloyd, Death Comes to the Village

After being seriously injured at Waterloo, Major Robert Kurland is back at his estate near the village of Kurland St. Mary to recover. One night, looking out his bedroom window, he sees an unidentified figure carrying a heavy load. Meanwhile, Lucy Harrington, the vicar’s oldest daughter, is disturbed when one of the young female servants disappears without even collecting the wages she’s owed. When Lucy visits Robert (an errand of mercy on her father’s behalf), they compare notes and team up to discover what’s going on, soon uncovering evidence of theft and murder. I really enjoyed this cozy historical mystery! While Lucy seems to have a bit more freedom than is period-appropriate (conversing with the major in his bedroom, gasp!), she’s not just a progressive 21st-century heroine in period garb. The mystery is solid, though not brilliant, and I appreciated that the plot wasn’t overly convoluted. I’m definitely interested in continuing with the series; it looks like there are seven more books, and luckily my library seems to have them all!

Mini-Review: Bridge, Hazard, Stardust

Barry Hughart, Bridge of Birds

Number Ten Ox is a peasant living in the Chinese village of Ku-fu. When all the village children suddenly contract a mysterious illness, Ox must find a wise man to discover the cause of the sickness and its cure. He finds Master Li, a very old man with “a slight flaw in his character,” and the two of them travel throughout China seeking the Great Root of Power that will supposedly cure the sickness. Along the way, they have a series of adventures involving thievery, beautiful women, murderous dictators, divine entities, and the occasional ghost. This is a fun picaresque novel full of improbable stories and sly jokes. Master Li and Number Ten Ox are the only characters with any depth, but I enjoyed them both immensely, and I also liked how some of the secondary characters kept reentering the narrative. I’m glad I finally got around to reading this one; it isn’t particularly deep or life-changing, but it’s certainly an entertaining read!

Stella Riley, Hazard

Aristide isn’t interested in love or marriage; right now he’s more focused on running the high-class gaming hall he co-owns. Meanwhile, Genevieve is a recent widow who’s desperate to marry again and escape the clutches of her overbearing brothers. Seizing upon a slight prior acquaintance with Aristide, Genevieve makes a shocking proposal, and Aristide is surprised by how tempted he is to accept. Meanwhile, the long-brewing romance between Aristide’s sister, Madeleine, and Nicholas, the duke of Rockliffe’s brother, finally comes to a head. I liked this book a lot, though I found Aristide’s story much more interesting than Madeleine’s. He’s learned to hide his true feelings under an iron mask of self-control, and it’s lovely to watch his growing affection for Genevieve transform him. Genevieve is also a deeply sympathetic character, though I felt she healed awfully quickly from her traumatic past, which includes an abusive husband as well as the aforementioned brothers. Overall, though, a great read in a great series!

Neil Gaiman, Stardust

The village of Wall has long stood at the border of Faerie, but none of the villagers has dared to cross that boundary — until 17-year-old Tristran Thorn vows to bring back a fallen star to impress the prettiest girl in the village. He didn’t count on the fact that the fallen star is actually a young woman, Yvaine; further, he’s not the only person seeking her. Also on the star’s track are the sons of Stormhold, who want a magical token she possesses, and a witch who needs the star’s heart to restore her youth. This novel is very atmospheric and brilliantly conjures up both the beauty and danger of Faerie. Tristran is a likable everyman hero, not too brave and not too clever. The book’s pacing is a bit off, for me — a ton of time is spent setting up the world, and I don’t think Tristran even gets to Faerie until about halfway through. Then he and Yvaine have some adventures that are briefly mentioned in a throwaway sentence or two, but I would have loved to learn more about them! If you’re looking for a book that gives gothic fairytale vibes, this is an excellent choice, but if you prefer a snappier plot in your fantasy novels, I’d look elsewhere.

Mini-Reviews: Plumeria, Wake-Up, Shadow

Lauren Willig, The Passion of the Purple Plumeria

Gwen Meadows, a “spinster” in her mid-40s, is publicly the chaperone of her young relative, Miss Jane Wooliston — and privately a principal member of the League of the Pink Carnation. When Jane’s younger sister disappears from school, Gwen and Jane immediately suspect spy-related foul play. But another girl is also missing: the daughter of Colonel William Reid, a retired East India Company officer who’s only recently come to England. Gwen and William team up to look for the missing girls, finding a legendary Indian treasure — and love — in the process. This is another fun installment of the Pink Carnation series, and it’s nice that Miss Gwen (usually reduced to comic relief) finally gets her turn in the spotlight. It’s refreshing and sadly rare to read about more mature adults finding romance! This isn’t one of my favorites in the series, but it’s still a good read — can’t believe there are only two more books to go!

Beth O’Leary, The Wake-Up Call

Izzy and Lucas are colleagues at the Forest Manor Hotel, and they can’t stand each other. Izzy is a sunshiny people-pleaser who always goes above and beyond, whereas Lucas is grumpy, reserved, and blunt to the point of rudeness. Further, Izzy confessed a crush to Lucas about a year ago, and he (seemingly) responded in a particularly cruel and insensitive way. Of course, the truth is more complicated — and now that Izzy and Lucas are being forced to work together to save their beloved hotel, their mutual “hatred” is turning into something else entirely. I really loved Beth O’Leary’s debut novel, The Flatshare, but her subsequent books have been too angsty and/or gimmicky for me. This book, however, feels like a return to form; it’s just a strong, well-written romantic comedy with some bonus holiday charm thrown in. The conflict between Izzy and Lucas centers around miscommunication, which may be frustrating for some, but to me their misunderstandings made sense given their very different personalities. Fans of the enemies-to-lovers trope should definitely check this one out!

Philip Pullman, The Shadow in the North

Six years after the events of The Ruby in the Smoke, Sally Lockhart has established her own financial consulting firm. One of her clients loses her life’s savings when a shipping firm unexpectedly collapses, and she asks Sally to find out why. Meanwhile, Sally’s friends try to help a magician who’s receiving death threats. When the two cases turn out to be connected, Sally and her friends must go up against a ruthless businessman who will use any means necessary, including murder, to stop them. I’m continuing to enjoy the Sally Lockhart series, both for the immersive Victorian London setting and for the main characters, particularly Sally herself, her beau Fred, and their Cockney friend Jim. The book may be slightly too busy; there are a plethora of minor characters and plot strands that need following. There are also more than a few heartbreaking moments. But I nevertheless liked this book a lot and look forward to continuing with the series.

Mini-Reviews: Wicked, Left-Handed, Madam

Julia Quinn, When He Was Wicked

Michael Stirling is known throughout society as “the Merry Rake,” but despite his myriad sexual conquests, he’s been in love with Francesca Bridgerton since the moment he saw her. Unfortunately, she was betrothed to his cousin John at the time and is now John’s wife. When John dies unexpectedly, Michael can no longer hide his true feelings, but can he pursue a relationship with Francesca without dishonoring his cousin’s memory? I wanted to like this book more than I did. I enjoy a hero who pines for the heroine, but in this case I didn’t understand why Michael was so obsessed with Francesca. He’s already in love with her when the story begins, so we don’t see what makes her so special to him. Further, he “courts” her exclusively by seducing her, so their romantic relationship is based entirely on sex, which I didn’t find particularly appealing. I’ve really liked some books in the Bridgerton series, but this one just wasn’t for me.

Garth Nix, The Left-Handed Booksellers of London

Eighteen-year-old Susan Arkshaw has come to London to find the father she’s never met. She tracks down Frank Thringley, an old friend of her mother’s, to see if he knows anything about her father — but she arrives just in time to see him crumble into dust at the prick of a hatpin. The hatpin’s wielder is Merlin, who describes himself as a “left-handed bookseller” and tells Susan she is in grave danger. He explains that the Old World of myths, legends, and ancient powers is real, and it’s starting to intrude dangerously into the ordinary world — unless Susan and the booksellers can stop it. This is a really creative YA adventure novel that seems intended to introduce readers to (or reinforce their love of) British fantasy fiction and mythology. I really liked all the literary allusions and the occasional humorous banter, but the book is a bit too episodic and plot-driven for me — too many action sequences, not enough character development. Overall, I liked but didn’t love it, and I probably won’t read the sequel.

Mary Stewart, Madam, Will You Talk?

Charity Selborne is a young Englishwoman on holiday in the South of France. At her hotel in Avignon, she befriends a 13-year-old boy named David and gradually realizes that something is very wrong in his life. She then learns that David’s father, an accused murderer, is at large and has followed David to France. Charity’s decision to help David plunges her into days of suspense and fear, during which she encounters a mystery with its roots in World War II and finds love in an unexpected place. I really enjoy Mary Stewart’s novels of romantic suspense, though they all follow the same basic pattern: beautiful girl in exotic location finds danger and romance. But this is one of her strongest books, in my opinion — the plot is nice and twisty, and there’s a very memorable car chase. Recommended if you like this type of book!

Mini-Reviews: Daughter, Marry, Devil

Juliet Marillier, Daughter of the Forest

Sorcha has lived an idyllic life with her father and six older brothers at Sevenwaters, a small Irish estate in the heart of a magical forest. But things change when her father marries Lady Oonagh, whose malicious sorcery soon tears Sorcha’s family apart. When Oonagh ensnares her brothers in a dreadful curse, Sorcha must perform an impossible task to save them — and she must remain silent till the task is complete. As she struggles with her task, she suffers many trials, including abduction by Britons and life among a hostile people. This was a reread for me, yet the book still completely sucked me in. The pace is incredibly slow, but I think the languorous plot adds to the dreamy, immersive nature of the world Marillier creates. It also lets readers get to know Sorcha well enough to find her extraordinary endurance believable. I love the book’s romance and its hopeful, yet not entirely happy, ending. I’ve enjoyed a few other books by Marillier, and I’m now inspired to dig deeper into her backlist!

Anne Gracie, Marry in Haste

Major Calbourne Rutherford has just returned to England after the Napoleonic wars, only to find that his brother has died and he’s inherited an earldom. Cal intends to discharge his necessary duties quickly and then leave the country, but his plans change when he learns that his teenage half-sisters are getting into mischief. Unable to curb their behavior himself, he seeks out their former teacher, Emmaline Westwood, for help. She refuses his offer of employment, so in desperation he offers her a marriage of convenience instead. This Regency romance isn’t reinventing the wheel; it’s just a solid, fun, formulaic example of the genre, and that’s not a bad thing! Part of the joy of reading romance — and genre fiction in general — is that you know what you’re getting, and there’s comfort in that familiarity. I’m also a fan of the marriage-of-convenience trope, so I am definitely interested in continuing with the series. Recommended for historical romance fans!

Richard Osman, The Last Devil to Die

The Thursday Murder Club is back in business when Kuldesh Sharma, an antiques dealer who helped them on their previous case, is shot in what appears to be a drug deal gone wrong. Kuldesh was temporarily in possession of a box of heroin worth £100,000, but now it’s gone missing. Who has the heroin, and did that person also murder Kuldesh? As always, the characters and humor make this series a delight; at one point, Joyce describes the bracelet her daughter’s boyfriend gave her as “a nice thought.” One of my favorite aspects of the series is that every character is portrayed as a real, complex human being — even the drug dealers and other bad guys. This book is a bit heavier than usual because it deals more with Elizabeth’s husband Stephen’s struggles with dementia. But it’s still a very good read, and I’m eagerly awaiting the net book — though the author has announced he’s taking a break and writing about new characters right now, alas!

Mini-Reviews: Agreeable, Dangerous, Ruby

Julia Seales, A Most Agreeable Murder

In the English village of Swampshire, everyone is governed by the strict rules of etiquette handed down by its founder. Women are expected to pursue only ladylike occupations such as embroidery, but Beatrice Steele has a secret fascination with crime-solving. She knows she must hide her interest, lest she be stigmatized as a “morbid creep” and rendered unmarriageable. But when an eligible bachelor is murdered at a local ball, Beatrice can’t help enthusiastically pursuing an investigation, with the help of a surly yet handsome detective. This is a fun historical mystery set in a heightened reality: Swampshire is beset by comically terrible weather and infested with “squelch holes,” and Beatrice’s youngest sister might be a werewolf. It’s all very silly, but I enjoyed the book’s colorful characters and its skewering of various historical romance tropes. If there’s ever a sequel, I will definitely seek it out!

Darcie Wilde, And Dangerous to Know

The stakes are higher than ever in Rosalind Thorne’s latest case: Lady Melbourne, a leader of London society, has hired her to recover some stolen letters. Lady Melbourne’s daughter-in-law is Lady Caroline Lamb, whose shocking love affair with Lord Byron has led many to believe she’s insane, so it’s especially important that the letters’ potentially scandalous contents are never publicized. Complicating matters is the fact that a woman was murdered at the gates of Melbourne House, and Rosalind suspects that the two incidents are connected. I liked this book a bit more than the previous one in the series; the mystery hangs together pretty well, although it’s almost peripheral to the intrigues swirling around the Melbourne clan. I’m also glad that things seem to be moving forward in Rosalind’s personal life (and in those of her friends as well). While I’m pretty confident that this series won’t be an all-time favorite, I’m looking forward to the next book!

Philip Pullman, The Ruby in the Smoke

Sixteen-year-old Sally Lockhart is left alone in the world after her father’s tragic death overseas. When she receives an anonymous note telling her to “beware the seven blessings,” it’s the first of many strange mysteries Sally must unravel. For instance: Who burgled her room, and what was he or she looking for? How did her father really meet his end? Where is the priceless Indian ruby that apparently belongs to Sally? And why does the evil Mrs. Holland want Sally dead? This is a compelling YA adventure novel that apes the drama and sensationalism of Victorian penny dreadfuls. Some of the plot machinations feel a bit over the top, and there’s some unpleasant stereotyping of Chinese characters. But the depiction of the seamier side of Victorian London is fascinating, and Sally and her friends are intelligent, courageous, interesting characters. I’m excited to read more of their adventures in subsequent books!