Review: The Welsh Girl

The Welsh GirlPeter Ho Davies, The Welsh Girl

Set in North Wales just after D-Day, this novel weaves together the stories of three people who are all struggling with the ways in which the war has made them question their identity. Esther is the eponymous Welsh girl who works as a barmaid but dreams of life outside her tiny village. When an English soldier takes advantage of her, Esther has to face her future and determine what kind of woman she will become. Karsten is a young German soldier who has surrendered to the English and must now live with the shame of being a coward; as he sees the Allies reclaim more and more of Europe, he also questions his belief in German supremacy. Meanwhile, Rotheram is a German man with a Jewish father who fled Germany in the early days of the war. He now works as a translator for the British and interrogates German prisoners, but he is conflicted about where his loyalties truly lie.

Lately I’ve been really interested in books that are set during World War II, so I had high hopes for this novel. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to my expectations, which is largely the fault of the cover blurb. I thought the book would mostly focus on the relationship between Esther and Karsten and the obstacles they’d have to face being on opposite sides of a war. But while a relationship does grow between them, it doesn’t actually happen until well after the halfway point of the novel. Most of the book is just setting up the conflict, as Esther’s background, the Welsh attitude toward the war, and Karsten’s military career are described in plodding detail. I wouldn’t actually call the book romantic at all — which is not a problem, except that the blurb led me to believe otherwise! I do think that the novel raises some interesting thoughts relating to World War II and war in general, so it was probably worth reading for those insights. (There was also a line near the end of the book about the liberation of Bergen-Belsen that got me right in the gut.) But overall, although I wanted to like this book, it just didn’t do anything for me.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Review: The Welsh Girl

  1. That’s so interesting – my edition was a UK one and the blurb implied absolutely nothing about romance, just describes the three main characters and how they will come to question their deepest loyalties (in the words of the blurb). The sort-of romance took me nicely by surprise! I can see how selling it as a romance would make this extremely disappointing. As it was, I agree totally that this was a very very slow novel, though I did find it interesting to learn about the Welsh POW camps and what it was like in Wales at the time.

    • It’s amazing how differently people can experience a book based solely on the way it’s marketed. I do think I would have enjoyed this more if the U.S. blurb hadn’t promised a romance…it definitely colored my expectations quite a bit!

  2. Pingback: Around the World in 12 Books Challenge Wrap-up | You Book Me All Night Long

  3. Pingback: Historical Fiction 2013 Challenge Wrap-up | You Book Me All Night Long

  4. Pingback: Around the World in 12 Books Challenge – 2013 Round-up | Giraffe Days

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s