Mini-Reviews: Plumeria, Wake-Up, Shadow

Lauren Willig, The Passion of the Purple Plumeria

Gwen Meadows, a “spinster” in her mid-40s, is publicly the chaperone of her young relative, Miss Jane Wooliston — and privately a principal member of the League of the Pink Carnation. When Jane’s younger sister disappears from school, Gwen and Jane immediately suspect spy-related foul play. But another girl is also missing: the daughter of Colonel William Reid, a retired East India Company officer who’s only recently come to England. Gwen and William team up to look for the missing girls, finding a legendary Indian treasure — and love — in the process. This is another fun installment of the Pink Carnation series, and it’s nice that Miss Gwen (usually reduced to comic relief) finally gets her turn in the spotlight. It’s refreshing and sadly rare to read about more mature adults finding romance! This isn’t one of my favorites in the series, but it’s still a good read — can’t believe there are only two more books to go!

Beth O’Leary, The Wake-Up Call

Izzy and Lucas are colleagues at the Forest Manor Hotel, and they can’t stand each other. Izzy is a sunshiny people-pleaser who always goes above and beyond, whereas Lucas is grumpy, reserved, and blunt to the point of rudeness. Further, Izzy confessed a crush to Lucas about a year ago, and he (seemingly) responded in a particularly cruel and insensitive way. Of course, the truth is more complicated — and now that Izzy and Lucas are being forced to work together to save their beloved hotel, their mutual “hatred” is turning into something else entirely. I really loved Beth O’Leary’s debut novel, The Flatshare, but her subsequent books have been too angsty and/or gimmicky for me. This book, however, feels like a return to form; it’s just a strong, well-written romantic comedy with some bonus holiday charm thrown in. The conflict between Izzy and Lucas centers around miscommunication, which may be frustrating for some, but to me their misunderstandings made sense given their very different personalities. Fans of the enemies-to-lovers trope should definitely check this one out!

Philip Pullman, The Shadow in the North

Six years after the events of The Ruby in the Smoke, Sally Lockhart has established her own financial consulting firm. One of her clients loses her life’s savings when a shipping firm unexpectedly collapses, and she asks Sally to find out why. Meanwhile, Sally’s friends try to help a magician who’s receiving death threats. When the two cases turn out to be connected, Sally and her friends must go up against a ruthless businessman who will use any means necessary, including murder, to stop them. I’m continuing to enjoy the Sally Lockhart series, both for the immersive Victorian London setting and for the main characters, particularly Sally herself, her beau Fred, and their Cockney friend Jim. The book may be slightly too busy; there are a plethora of minor characters and plot strands that need following. There are also more than a few heartbreaking moments. But I nevertheless liked this book a lot and look forward to continuing with the series.

2 thoughts on “Mini-Reviews: Plumeria, Wake-Up, Shadow

Leave a comment